About the College Hill Historic District | Neighborhood website | Map | Recent Sales
A note to Realtors and prospective home buyers about buying properties in historic districts
Single-Family Homes
214 S. Mendenhall Street — contract pending as of June 3, 2017
Blog post
- $359,000
- 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, 2,810 square feet
- Price/square foot: $128
- Built in 1900
- Listed May 20, 2017
- Last sale: $255,000, February 2003
- $239,900
- 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 1,818 square feet
- Price/square foot: $132
- Built: 1920
- Listed: May 1, 2017
- Last sale: $229,000, May 2006
- $235,000
- 3 bedrooms, 1 1/2 bathrooms, 1,466 square feet
- Price/square foot: $160
- Built in 1982
- Listed February 3, 2017
- Last sale: September 2015, $122,745 (foreclosure auction)
- Last non-foreclosure sale: February 2009, $170,000
Multi-Family Homes
- $341,000
- 3,099 square feet
- Price/square foot: $110
- Built in 1920
- Listed May 1, 2017
- Last sale: 1995, price not available in online records
- Note: Three apartments: 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom upstairs; 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom upstairs; and 3 bedroom, 2 bathrooms on main level.
500 South Mendenhall Street — contract pending as of May 10, 2017
- $285,000
- 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, 2,587 square feet (per county tax listing), divided into three apartments,
- Price/square foot: $110
- Built in 1900
- Listed April 13, 2017
- Last sale: October 2003, $240,000
- Note: Originally a single-family home, now divided into three apartments. Previous listing stated: “Appraiser suggested if $10K spent could convert back to single family dwelling and per sq ft would increase.” Previously listed without a sale in March 2015 (19 months), October 2013 (10 months) and February 2011 (12 months). Asking prices ranged from $329,000 down to $275,000 when last listing ended.
Condos and Townhouses
801 West McGee Street, Unit 21
- $113,000 (originally listed at $124,900)
- 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, 917 square feet
- Price/square foot: $125
- Built in 1905
- Listed June 20, 2016
- Last sale: January 1990, $50,000
